Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login

Featured in Collections

eyes by linscaged

Fanfiction or Literature by Raph1966

More from DeviantArt


Submitted on
November 6, 2007
File Size
10.8 KB


10 (who?)
The Drawn Book As Art And Literature
(Originally composed for an academic comics symposium)

As proof that the drawn book is art and literature, I am going to build my article around one publication or source: my own books.

I have chosen this approach because my work is original.  It is not couched in the “comics” tradition.  I did not learn to draw or write in that tradition.  My work entered that publishing world fully formed after years of private practice..  

If anything, my work is based in the classical arts and literatures of the world.  My first writing model is Kipling, with his poetic English, flavored with the Hindi vernacular with which he was raised.  My own work reflects my long study of the German language (including a B.A. in German language and Literature, from Ohio State University) with its ability to easily express complex and esoteric concepts.  It's hard to say complicated things in English.  German, with the pop-bead nature of its syllabic and meaning system, allows a speaker or writer to construct brand-new words to express the most nuanced meanings.  A German writer can readily express new concepts with words never found in the dictionary.  For example, rather than researching the German word for “centaur,” I constructed Halbpferd, literally “half-horse.”  The German word is from the Greek, Kentaur, but I wanted a native construction to express the folk nature of the tales I would be telling (It happened that Halbpferd has already been used in German literature as a word for “centaur.”).

My artwork shows influences of several line-drawing traditions, most of them folk or ancient, and therefore anonymous.  The strongest influence is one which has worked upon much of the art of the western world for more than a century – the tomb paintings of ancient Egypt.  This typically African art, with its supremely refined sense of line and weight, its attenuated physical forms and design-like repetitive patterns, its use of sacred design symbol, in everything from the edge of a linen skirt to thousands of leaves or waves of water, has always been a model for my own art.

Raised in the Pacific Northwest region of the American continent, I was also very much influenced by the native Form-Line designs, as described by Bill Holm in his now-classic Northwest Coast Indian Art: An Analysis of Form.  The dignity and clarity of the form, with its powerful sweeping lines and paring down of detail, as well as the de-construction and re-construction of natural forms into what can almost be read as a form of hieroglyphic (i.e., a killer whale with a human eye form is not a killer whale, but a man in killer whale form, or a killer whale wearing human form while interacting with the human world), did much to help me form my own viewpoint of the line-work form.

One of my former publishers, Edd Vick, has said that I had almost re-invented the comic form independent of any extant tradition.  Without reference to published comics, I built stories using art and writing, placing six equal panels, divided purely for mathematical balance, upon each page.  The original manuscripts of this work can be found in San Diego State University Library's Special Collections (refer to:…

When I was first approached by an editor, Steve Gallacci of Thoughts and Images, and later published by Eclipse Comics, I did very little to bring my style into line with that more traditionally used by mainstream comics.  Without changing the style of either my art or writing, I opened up the layout and made it more approachable by a public.  Other than that, I retained my artistic control.

Part of the problem with comics, and the reason they have been considered a mere production model, was that they were based on teams.  These teams were originated by Will Eisner, one of the founding developers of the first forms.  His own work – especially in his well-received A Life, In Pictures -- uses fiction to tell the story of ancestors and relatives, especially one man who paid less talented workers to become part of a production-line that produced painted faux wood bedsteads, freeing up this man to do more of the artistic work.  Eisner introduced this own method in his early publication career, bringing together a group of artists and writers who were happy to do piece work in a production-line atmosphere.

This production-line method works if the creator is a writer, an artist, a colorist or letterer – but what about the author who can do it all?  Eisner was one of these, but in opening the field to the less versatile members of the artistic community, he trapped other artists -- like himself capable of completing the project on their own -- in a system based on nothing but piece work, with no options or opportunities for the complete author.

While very few of the writers, artists, or letterers involved in comic books can be viewed as second-rate talents, this model informed the whole future of the art form.  Creators were viewed as simply replaceable cogs, in a culture of imitation that supported nothing but a publisher marketing model.  

Mr. Eisner meant well, but mis-interpretation of the system by others who didn't understand his original purpose,  has led to an art-form that traditionally became as cookie-cutter as a Ford assembly line.  A creator of Eisner's stature as a thoroughbred could work within the system without becoming a driven hack.  Very few others could.  A writer or artist, no matter how talented, could be replaced by the next rising young star -- with an art style that looked just like the old guys' – and often was, because the star author's salary and fees had risen with his career, and anyone who could be hired at a much lower entry cost to the publisher could threaten a career.  Worse, the individual creator who could accomplish all parts of this extremely labor-intensive art form was forced into the piece-work model.  Small wonder that the writing and art in comics has been so hard to tell apart.  Individuality was always at the mercy of the bottom line.

Enter the computer and the internet.  In a very short time, print-on-demand technologies, such as the very accessible and more professional (acquired by as its POD supplier) opened up the printing field to everyone.  All a creator needed was the ability to use basic Adobe programs, or scrape up a few bucks for layout at one of the upload sites.

Marketing ranged from private websites to's Advantage and Marketplace programs.  Artists and writers like Jane Irwin became marketplace masters.  Her list of distributors is one of the best (  Her own Vogelein books are a clear example of the kind of talent and originality that can flourish is a creator is allowed to fly free.

Webcomics have blasted open the walls of traditional comics in everything from layout to payment plans.  As an example, Joey Manley's – later expanded into the empire – allows total creator control.  Creators can even make their own ad deals on the sites through www.projectwonderfulcom  Without the stultifying control of market-based genres, authors are free to create thousands of different forms, with a grace and complexity comparable to any literature or art form.

Comics can become a true form of art and literature now, because there is nothing to control or stop it, even more than in prose publishing.  Comics creators are very publishing savvy.  To be a self-publisher is a mark of honor within the field, because it reflects – on top of amazing talent and the ability to turn out masses of incredible work --  a business sense and work ethic unlike anywhere else in publishing.  Comics authors commonly have their own series of ISBNs, and know where to get SANs, ISSN's and LCCN's.  They know how to use all the Adobe layout and upload software.  

Prose authors, on the other hand, may be falling into the former comics trap.  Once the Harry Potter series comes to an end, any author who may fit the bill, regardless of style or ability, can be grabbed and sent into that marketing niche.  Prose authors, without knowledge of how to control their own art form, are quickly being chopped into genres as cookie cutter as any of the old tights-n-fights comics series.  The only prose forms which may retain their individuality are poetry and mystery – the latter will accept any form of story or style as long as a mystery is stuck into it somewhere.

Traditional publishers count on genre or box thinking to make their products more marketable.  It seems as though the No-Child-Left-Behind test system in America are breaking down the ability for original thought, or at least that seems to be its intent.  Again, the internet, with its constant accessibility for discussion, dispute and research, may be doing an end-run around what seems to be the attempt of the New School system to lower the educations levels (actual intent of the system to be discussed in another place).  While the average reader is content with genre books directed at the perceived housewife or teenager, the comic book reader is the very market that has refused to be kept at the box level, and knows how to get around or past it.

With full freedom of marketing and production, comics creators have been writing about the entire range of human experience, from tragedy to comedy – often in the same books, following the long European tradition of the ambiguity of existence.  Art forms are being built from all the traditions of the world and all time, or being developed independently by artists who are as free as their art.  

The day may come when the prose writers learn how to get out of the boxes and join the revolution.  Will Eisner's original intent of artistic freedom for artists and writers may be realized at last.

Donna Barr 29 August, 2007…
For the comics educational week.
Add a Comment:
JuneRevolver Featured By Owner Aug 13, 2010  Student Filmographer
hehe it's truth.
JuneRevolver Featured By Owner Aug 13, 2010  Student Filmographer
(now that I have re-read it after taking an advil/excedrin combo...) In terms of your style, subconsciously I think I had the connection to that very linear style what that's presented in many folk drawings and such but you seem to have combined it with a modern flare and it works so very well.

I honestly use to (until reading this article) think that self-publishing was bad because it'd mean that no one was willing to publish yourself for you... while the greatest tool of the artist may be the pencil, another great tool is without doubt the internet (this make me so fortunate that I am growing up in an era where it's simpler XD i dunno).

While I may not be a fan of many of the comic-movie adaptations, I do think that they have been helping the industry somewhat because they have been driving the common eye into the more unseen media- the comic/graphic novel media. Often in cases, when you say you read comics people don't think you're too odd (unless your a girl >_<).
I feel that (especially since "Watchmen") comic books are being taken with more of a serious tone...

I don't really know what the heck I was trying to say but that last bit of the article about prose learners just made me think of that.
skunktoy Featured By Owner Nov 21, 2007
Very interesting, and I'm surprised and happy to see a reference to Jane's work... ;-)
DonnaBarr Featured By Owner Nov 23, 2007  Professional General Artist
She's done some wonderful things -- and she's a model for marketing.

skunktoy Featured By Owner Nov 23, 2007
She is? Cool! I haven't seen her since she moved away from the Ann Arbor area,
so I'm happy if she is doing well. ;-)

Her work, like yours, is also wonderfully different!
DonnaBarr Featured By Owner Nov 26, 2007  Professional General Artist
Thank you! I'm sure she'd love to hear from you -- her email is on her site.

Majnouna Featured By Owner Nov 8, 2007  Professional General Artist
That was a very interesting read, that made me miss the substance and originality I used to see in our university papers. I share your misgivings about the fordian break-down of making comics. I understand its necessity in a mass consumer market (not that I approve of the market itself) but I am more intrigued by what an author can produce from start to finish on his or her own. It's brilliant that we now have so much more opportunities to have creator control, even though it means the competition is a lot thicker.
DonnaBarr Featured By Owner Nov 8, 2007  Professional General Artist
I agree with what you've said except about "competition."

An truly original creator actually has no competition. No one else can produce what that artist/writer can produce, except as a developing genre.

I've long ascribed to the principal -- most easily described by a simple phrase -- that, "The more bees, the more flowers." Rather than being competitors, the truly original creators bring in more readers to the art form.

Keith Knight (KChronichles), Stephen Notley (Bob The Angry Flower) and myself (Desert Peach) are, among growing hundreds, among the original creators whose readership enjoys each others work, but do not mistake them for the same source.

They're the gang in the small press neighborhood of SDCC City.

Majnouna Featured By Owner Nov 8, 2007  Professional General Artist
That's funny, I had actually originally ended my post with this exact thought, but removed it because it was getting too long. Yes, I know what you're saying.
Raphir Featured By Owner Nov 7, 2007
Very interesting, and well put, though I think the way you put the Fordian-like model of making comics as too much the bad guy.
Though it is true all you mention about the systems tendency of creating not-so-artistic comics, I think it's hardly as guilty as the super-hero genre to which comics were eventually bound. Much like animations (be it on tv or cinema), they were quickly associated with children's interests, due to it's greater ease of creating fantasy and it's ease of being understood and quickly read, assets that make it more interesting to children than other forms of story-telling.
And in the ever lasting lack of respect for children and that which interests them, comics thus became shunned and ignored.
If you have not yet read it, I recommend the book "Discovering Comics" by Scott McCloud. Has some interesting insight on the subject.

But I must say it again: very interesting article, very well written! It was great reading, thanks for it!
Add a Comment: